Photo: Ron Galella, Ltd./Ron Galella Collection via Getty, Warner Brothers/Getty

Robert Deniro, Al Pacino

Al PacinoandRobert De Nirofamously never acted together in a scene until 1995’sHeat. Now, social media users are pitting the two movie legends against each other in a new way.

On Saturday, writerAshley Reesewent viral on Twitter when she asked her followers (while at a wedding) to determine who was more attractive as a young man: Pacino, now 83, or De Niro, now 79.

“At a wedding and having a big debate rn. Please vote,” Reese wrote in her post. “Who was hotter?”

As 277,372 votes trickled in before the poll closed on Sunday, Reese appeared to chime in largely for team Pacino, rhetorically wondering whether other Twitter users had seen his 1975 movieDog Day Afternoonin a follow-uppostto the poll.

“HAVE YOU PPL NOT SEEN DOG DAY AFTERNOON???” she wrote.

“Oh damn,” Kaling wrote, though it was unclear whether she was offering support to Pacino, De Niro, or simply expressing surprise at the poll’s close race.

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Warner Brothers/Getty

Robert De Niro leaning against a wall in a scene from the film ‘Mean Streets’, 1973.

“This 50/50 tie is incredible,” Reese wrote after the final tallies were counted. “You’re really a yung Pacino or a yung di Nero.”

“More people voted in this poll than some local elections,” she added in anotherpostwithin the thread.

Steve Wood/Express/Getty

Al Pacino, in London. After making his name in The Godfather and Serpico, he was finally awarded an Best Actor Oscar for his role in Scent of a Woman.

Pacino and De Niro both broke into the film industry in the late 1960s and early ’70s. The two famously costarred in 1974’s sequelThe Godfather Part II, though they shared no screen time as De Niro played a young version of Vito Corleone in flashbacks while Pacino reprised his role as Michael Corleone in the movie’s present-day storyline.

The duo reunited to play a police officer (Pacino) and a professional criminal (De Niro) hunting for each other in 1995’sHeat, which marked the first time the two actors actually appeared onscreen together more than 20 years afterThe Godfather Part II. Since then, Pacino and De Niro — the latter of whomrecently welcomed his seventh child— have also led movies like 2008’sRighteous Killand 2019’sThe Irishman.

“I’m glad everyone had fun,” Reesewroteon Twitter Monday, in response to a Vulture social media post jokingly referring to the weekend Twitter poll as “the year’s most important election.”

source: people.com